questions public servants are afraid to answer

e - Voice Of Human Rights Watch - e-news weekly

Spreading the light of humanity & freedom

Editor: Nagaraj.M.R....vol.4 . issue.42......18/10/2008

TO PROTECT HUMAN RIGHTS OF INNOCENTS VISIT ,http://www.amnesty.org

Editorial : QUESTIONS PUBLIC SERVANTS ARE AFRAID TO ANSWER – Indian judges , Police & Public servants in the Witness Box

The police , judges , public servants , etc question the accussed persons , to ascertain the root cause of crime or dispute, to know the truth behind every actions. The police even apply 3^rd degree torture on commoners ( although it is illegal ) to elicit truth , information about crimes. When the same public wants to know the truth behind crimes involving police , judges & public servants , and seeking truth , answers , informations as per RTI ACT from police , judges & public servants , they are not answering lest the truth come out. They are citing one or the other technical reasons to hide information , to hide truth about crimes , to shield the criminals. If any of the following public servants truly stands for law , justice , truth , let them answer for the following questions publicly through media

CROSS EXAM OF HONOURABLE CHIEF JUSTICE OF INDIA , SUPREME COURT OF INDIA -

http://crosscji.blogspot.com/ , http://crossexamofchiefjustice.blogspot.com/ , http://crimesofsupremecourt.wordpress.com/ , http://crosscji.wordpress.com/ , http://crossexamofchiefjustice.wordpress.com/ ,

CROSS EXAM OF UNION HOME SECRETARY , GOI , NEW DELHI –

http://crosscji.blogspot.com/ , http://crossexamofchiefjustice.blogspot.com/ , http://crimesofsupremecourt.wordpress.com/ , http://crosscji.wordpress.com/ , http://crossexamofchiefjustice.wordpress.com/ ,

CROSS EXAM OF DG&IG OF POLICE , GOK , BANGALORE –

http://crosscji.blogspot.com/ , http://crossexamofchiefjustice.blogspot.com/ , http://crimesofsupremecourt.wordpress.com/ , http://crosscji.wordpress.com/ , http://crossexamofchiefjustice.wordpress.com/ ,

CROSS EXAM OF GOVERNOR , RESERVE BANK OF INDIA

 http://theftinrbi.blogspot.com/ , http://theftinrbi.rediffblogs.com/  , http://theftinrbi.wordpress.com/ 

CROSS EXAM OF MUDA COMMISSIONER , MUDA , MYSORE –

http://crimesofmuda.blogspot.com/ , http://manivannanmuda.blogspot.com/ , http://crimesatmudamysore.wordpress.com/ ,

CROSS EXAM OF BDA COMMISSIONER , BDA , BANGALORE –

http://crimesofbda.blogspot.com/ , http://bdacrimes.wordpress.com/ ,

The only thing corrupt public servants know is to neglect the complaints of public , if somebody pursues with his complaint he is silenced either by falsely fixing him up or by snatching his sources of livelihood or by finishing him off. But , at the end of the day no justice to common man. The corrupt public servant triumphs , injustice triumphs.

The essential feature , lifeline of democracy is information flow between

CITIZENS <– > PEOPLE'S REPRESENTATIVES <–> PUBLIC SERVANTS. The " Right to Expression " is a fundamental right , democratic right of every Indian citizen & also it is a basic human right. To express means to have proper access to information , assimilate it & respond. Inspite of fundamental right of expression TOGETHER WITH INFORMATION , the public servants rarely respected it. The public were forced to go to higher courts to secure their rights which took years & lot of money. The government with a good intention of giving information at affordable costs within a stipulated time frame has framed RTI ACT . IT has caused jitters among public servants , as the informations are opening-up their crimes , corruptions are coming to light. Now , they are opposing disclosing file notings.

The public servants while assuming the government office take a oath that they will carry on their duties without FEAR OR FAVOUR , WITHOUT ILL WILL , BIAS ON ANY GROUNDS & they will strictly uphold the rule of law. However the greedy , corrupt public servants are caste conscious , they base their judgements , reasonings on illegal grounds make notings favouring some , disapproving others. These file notings play a very important role in decision making in government service. As their file notings are not logically based , law abiding , but are based on bribe , favours , based on their personal feelings as human beings , the decisions arrived at based on those notings are not legal as per constitutional terms. This meats out injustices , this is what is happening in government service since independence. Now, RTI ACT wants to put an end to it , however public servants are opposing it. The public servants who oppose the disclosure of their file notings are one who are working against the spirit , letter & objective of their oath of office.

Right To Information Act was brought into force by government of india , to check corruption among public servants & to bring accountability in public service. The public servants are careless about RTI ACT , as they have cunningly diluted the penal provisions of the act & have curbed it's jurisdiction. On top of it , the public servants have hand picked their favourites & posted them to central information commission & state information commissions. At any cost , these public servants would not let the truth to come out into open , information to become public , as it will be their death knell pointing towards their ill-gotten wealth , riches.

The worst violators of RTI ACT are staff at president of india's secretariat & the staff at chief justice of india's office. What a shame to our democracy ?

HRW has appealed to CENTRAL INFORMATION COMMISSION & Karnataka State Information Commission , about violation of RTI ACT by public servants , their total disregard for the earlier directions of KSIC . Till date there is no word from KSIC or what action has been taken ? this gross negligence of duty by KSIC is aiding criminals / public servants in burying their crimes. Hereby HRW once again appeals to the KSIC to order the respective public servants to provide the information sought for , my KSIC COMPLAINT NO : KSIC/61/COMPLAINT/2006. If the constitutional body supposed protect the rights of citizens itself violates it , fate of citizens ? god , help my india. Jai hind , vande mataram. Your's sincerely,

Nagaraj.m.r.

DEATH PENALTY RIGHT OR WRONG ?

- AN APPEAL TO H.E.PRESIDENT OF INDIA & ALL HUMANE PERSONS

WHY DO WE KILL PEOPLE WHO KILL PEOPLE TO TELL PEOPLE THAT KILLING PEOPLE IS BAD ???

A criminal is not born, but made by social circumstances. For the crime scenario in India , every citizen of India is indirectly responsible. Our present inefficient, corrupt legal system , is wholly dependent on evidences which a rich criminal can create or destroy at his sweet will. Police forcibly take confessions from the accussed , by applying 3rd degree torture methods. Some of the judges are literally auctioning " judicial orders" for bribe. Due to all these reasons one cann't be 100% sure about one criminal's conviction. In such cases, capital punishment will be unfair & inhuman. It must be made mandatory, in all death penalty cases that polygraph, lie detector tests, etc must be conducted on " death convicts " , to know whether they are innocent or guilty inspite of hostile evidences. Fundamentally, the capital punishment has failed as a deterrent.

The people who clamour for continuance of death penalty are BIASED, INHUMAN, BUTCHERS & CANIBALS. Why don't they ask for death penalty to policemen, who murder people through 3rd degree torture, in lock-ups & fake encounters ? why don't they ask for death penalty to corrupt judges who sells judicial orders for bribe ? why don't they ask for death penalty to builders who cause building collapses, resulting in mass murders ? why don't they ask for death penalty to corrupt government doctors who refuses to treat poor patient without bribe, causing the murder of poor patient ? why don't they ask for death penalty to industrialist/ traders who sell adulterated food items, spurious drugs/ medicines, in turn causing mass murders ? why don't they ask for death penalty to corrupt government officials , who help criminals, industrialists? Why don't they ask for death penalty to politicians who create communal & other riots, who have ties with foreign intelligence agencies, terrorist outfits ? Why don't they ask for death penalty to mole in the P.M.O & the senior officers of National Security Council who passed on national secrets ? Why don't they ask for death penalty to public servants , ministers who gave aid , support to terrorist outfits like L.T.T.E out of government of india coffers , killing hundreds of srilankans , tamils ?

These are the guilty persons , criminals who don't personally , directly murder human beings but cunningly murder hundreds which go unnoticed by any. For the person who barbarically murders one human being you prescribe CAPITAL PUNISHMENT but for those who murder hundreds you say nothing why ? THEY WON'T ASK FOR IT, BECAUSE MOST OF THE PERSONS WHO ARE DEMANDING DEATH PENALTY ARE BIASED, SELFISH & BELONG TO ONE OF THE SECTIONS OF CRIMINALS MENTIONED ABOVE. They lack objectivity.

Death penalty is the ultimate . cruel , inhuman and degrading punishment. It violates the right to life Article 1 of universal declaration of human rights. It is irrevocable , prone to judicial errors and can be inflicted on innocents. It has never been shown to deter crime more effectively than other punishments. In most of the countries including india , judicial system is ineffective , inefficient to prosecute impartially both poor & rich criminals. Those condemned to death penalty mostly come from poor background who are unable to afford wise & articulate Advocates who can efficiently argue their case. Against these poor accussed , the criminal nexus of police-criminal-bureaucrat builds up fake evidences , extracts forced confessions by 3^rd degree torture. Most of death convicts world over belongs to either poor , TRIBALS , DALITS , etnic minorities , political dissidents , children , mentally ill. No rich & mighty criminal is ever prosecuted let alone hanged.

The judicial system which depends on technical facts like evidences lacks sense to figure out truth out of fake evidences , also as judges are human beings they are prone to err. Add to this corruption in judiciary. Death penalty is irreversible & irrevocable. In a mature democracy like U.S.A with relatively efficient judicial system itself hundreds of cases of death convicts were found to be wrong , convicts were found to be innocents upon review & were let free. Where as in india , the accussed lacks the wherewithal to argue his case in the first place then how can he arrange for case review ? no judge is god , if a hanged person is found to be innocent the judge doesn't has the ability to bring back the hanged person to life , do such judges have right to snatch away lives ?

Hereby e – VOICE OF HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH Urges H.E . PRESIDENT OF INDIA ,

1. to stay all death penalties until equitable criminal justice system with respect to above mentioned rich & mighty criminals is put into force .

2. until death penalty is abolished, to make poly graph, lie detector tests mandatory for all death convicts in a free & fair manner by a neutral authority , to ascertain whether the convict is really guilty or innocent of the alleged crime .

3. until death penalty is abolished , to give a peaceful choice of death to the death convicts like sleeping pill, injection, gun shot, etc instead of medieval & barbaric " death by hanging".

4. finally, to abolish death penalty from statuette books.

Edited, printed , published owned by NAGARAJ.M.R. @ #LIG-2 / 761,HUDCO FIRST STAGE ,OPP WATER WORKS , LAXMIKANTANAGAR , HEBBAL ,MYSORE - 570017 INDIA … cell :09341820313 home page : http://groups.yahoo.com/group/naghrw , http://groups.google.co.in/group/hrwepaper/ , http://evoiceofhumanrightswatch.wordpress.com/ , http://indiapolicelaw.blogspot.com/ , http://hrwpaper.blogspot.com/ , http://naghrw.tripod.com/evoice/ , http://e-voiceofhumanrightswatch.blogspot.com , contact : naghrw@yahoo.com , nagarajhrw@hotmail.com A member of AMNESTY INTERNATIONAL INDIA